The Investment Outlook
Hypothesizing about cultural and economic impacts at scale.
We have presented Bitcoin as an innovation in organization design. In this section, we will look at the broader impact of this innovation, its cultural relevance outside computer science, and how business may develop on top of it.
Cultural-historical timing is apt
Ward Cunningham is the engineer who coined the metaphor “technical debt,” and he draws a parallel between poor choices in software development and financial debt:
“I coined the debt metaphor to explain… cases where people would rush software out the door, and learn things, but never put that learning back in to the program. That, by analogy, was borrowing money thinking you never had to pay it back. Of course if you do that, eventually all your income goes to interest and your purchasing power goes to zero. By the same token, if you develop a program for a long period of time and only add features—never reorganizing it to reflect your understanding—then all of efforts to work on it take longer and longer.”
We can take this generally to mean that human systems must evolve as their designers learn more about how people behave inside them. If systems do not evolve along with our understanding of their purpose and dynamics, then these systems will fall into debt. In a public cryptocurrency system, stagnation means that malicious or negligent actors will eventually undermine the network.
The Occupy Wall Street movement emerged just two years after Bitcoin, in 2011, as a response to an un-audited $29 trillion Fed lending binge that exceeded the $700B TARP limit set by Congress. It can be said that OWS protested the origination of public debt by managers of the system.
Bitcoin is a similar protest for software developers who do not want technical debt originated for them by a managerial class. Both Bitcoin and Occupy Wall Street are responses to a perceived weakness in human systems, which occasionally allow small groups of managers to endebt everyone else. Bitcoin’s solution to this anti-pattern is to automate the management of important human systems in ways that are beneficial for participants.
Dilution of institutional boundaries may ensue
To understand the impact of Bitcoin, we return to Coase, and his theory that firms exist to reduce the transaction costs of specialists who collaborate in business. If peer to peer currency systems can lower financial transaction costs enough, they may eliminate the benefit of large firms entirely, replacing them with loosely-aggregated groups of SMBs sharing commonly-maintained infrastructure.
Coase writes that such a development would have massive societal impact, namely to subvert intellectual property laws and undermine the economics of large institutions:
"I showed in ‘The Nature of the Firm’ that, in the absence of transaction costs, there is no economic basis for the existence of the firm. What I showed in ‘The Problem of Social Cost’ was that, in the absence of transaction costs, it does not matter what the law is, since people can always negotiate without cost to acquire, sub-divide, and combine rights whenever this would increase the value of production. In such a world the institutions which make up the economic system have neither substance nor purpose. Cheung has even argued that, if transaction costs are zero, ‘the assumption of private property rights can be dropped without in the least negating the Coase Theorem’ and he is no doubt right.”
He elaborated in a subsequent book: “Businessmen will be constantly experimenting, controlling more or less, creating a moving equilibrium” between full-time and temporary contract labor. These impacts are also consistent with the stated goals of Satoshi Nakamoto and the Cypherpunks, whose resistance to institutional authority is rooted in a resentment for the managerial class and for the laws that protect and incentivize proprietary software.
Timothy May, the Intel executive and an original cypherpunk, predicted in 1992:
“Just as the technology of printing altered and reduced the power of medieval guilds and the social power structure, so too will cryptologic methods fundamentally alter the nature of corporations and of government interference in economic transactions. Combined with emerging information markets, crypto anarchy will create a liquid market for any and all material which can be put into words and pictures. And just as a seemingly minor invention like barbed wire made possible the fencing-off of vast ranches and farms, thus altering forever the concepts of land and property rights in the frontier West, so too will the seemingly minor discovery out of an arcane branch of mathematics come to be the wire clippers which dismantle the barbed wire around intellectual property.”
By eliminating the middlemen who mark up transaction costs at each stage of the value chain, SMBs that build on top of Bitcoin—especially cooperatives, nonprofits, and solo entrepreneurs—can trade their digital goods and services directly with end users at near zero marginal cost.
What cryptocurrency-based independent employment looks like
Individual entrepreneurs or small groups of developers can monetize free and open source projects in a number of ways. They can port the software onto new hardware and license it to businesses using that hardware, or they can sell teaching, support, and maintenance services. Contracting with tech companies to write programs using a free and open source library is another tactic. Indeed, many cryptocurrency developers have small consultancies that engage in consulting services; an example would be Ethereum co-founder Gavin Wood’s software agency Parity.
Older FOSS projects provide insights into the future of Bitcoin. In the case of Mozilla Firefox, intellectual property for the browser resides in a nonprofit corporation, the Mozilla Foundation, which is funded by donations and corporate grants. Taxable business activities are conducted in a wholly-owned for-profit subsidiary, the Mozilla Corporation, which was formed in August 2005. The corporation builds and distributes Firefox, and earns revenue from search referrals to Google and other search engines. This “dual entity” structure, with a foundation and a corporation, has been mimicked in other open source projects, including Bitcoin, which is maintained by a group of developers known as “Bitcoin Core,” some of whom have formed a commercial entity called Blockstream, which builds enterprise applications on top of Bitcoin for profit.
We have established that miners receive the lion’s share of wealth created by the Bitcoin network, and as a result, miners may become large sources of development capital. Many large-scale miners also manufacture machines, operate mining pools for other miners at a small fee.
Bounty-hunting is another approach to software entrepreneurship. Across all categories of work, freelancing employed 42 million Americans 10 years ago, and employs 53 million today, contributing over $715 billion a year to GDP. An increasing number of freelance platforms are offering work per-job, or in software terms, paying per problem solved.
Contract job boards such as GeekBoy, HackerOne, ZeroCOpter, CugCrowd, and Gitcoin allow developers to take contract development jobs on a per-problem basis, getting paid for their solution, not their time. Major technology corporations have used so-called “bug bounties” for decades; Augur, a popular blockchain project, can be seen below using the bounty hunting method to address a security vulnerability.
Perhaps the best implementation of a bitcoin-based bounty hunting system is BitHub, created by cypherpunk and Signal Messenger creator Moxie Marlinspike. BitHub does two things for Signal Messenger, which is free and open source software:
It allows Signal Messenger to take donations in bitcoin
It pays out this bitcoin to developers who fix bugs
In this way, existing products and services can hire and retain high-quality engineering talent, on a completely pseudonymous basis, and totally ad hoc, simply by offering a Bitcoin payment. Signal is amongst the highest-rated products in its category of “secure messenger applications.” It has been the chat application of choice for Hillary Clinton and her staff since at least August 2016, among other high-profile hacking targets.
Investigating the altcoin business model
Because Bitcoin develops slowly in the “bazaar,” and has no marketing department, it can appear from the outside fairly chaotic, and by all appearances “worse” than privately-developed alternatives. As free software, anyone can copy it and create such a private alternative.
Launching an altcoin gives you the financial runway to reproduce the stability of corporate employment, without answering to investors. (Just miners and users!) What is the distinction?
In a cryptocurrency context, a “scam” is a project which:
Will not grow or retain its developer pool, forestalling any chance at viral growth or stability.
Is actively shrinking in the number of full node operators and/or miners.
Will not provide a platform for the development of economic activity for any other reason.
Not all network operators are intentional scammers. For a new network, conscious choices which limit network growth may simply be a sign that the team is not confident in the network’s longevity. Thus, it can be easy to spot poor quality projects by their reliance on short-sighted tactics. While there is no firm litmus test for the viability of a project, the following characteristics can be considered red flags:
вклады bitcoin
эмиссия ethereum
bitcoin electrum bitcoin play bitcoin vip system bitcoin трейдинг bitcoin приложение tether bitcoin gambling puzzle bitcoin bitcoin код bitcoin super secp256k1 bitcoin bitcoin торрент bitcoin attack ethereum dark These wallets can be downloaded on any computer but can be accessed only from the system they are installed on, so you make sure the desktop or the machine on which you are downloading the desktop wallet is safe (has a backup and is in a secure location), and that you’re maintaining the hardware and not letting the machine go anywhere.putin bitcoin ethereum project alpha bitcoin tether верификация bitcoin настройка получить bitcoin time bitcoin bitcoin wm bitcoin rpg cryptocurrency tech bitcoin prosto криптовалюты bitcoin bitcoin blog android tether clicker bitcoin android tether
bitcoin покер service bitcoin
explorer ethereum bitcoin проблемы bitcoin 15 ethereum биржа
collector bitcoin bitcoin google bitcoin black ethereum core ico bitcoin bitcoin cudaminer bitcoin network ethereum прогнозы
bitcoin ecdsa code bitcoin продажа bitcoin agario bitcoin wikileaks bitcoin асик ethereum bitcoin symbol bitcoin gambling bitcoin arbitrage новости bitcoin ethereum ethereum проекты калькулятор monero bitcoin poloniex
british bitcoin
bitcoin china bitcoin monkey ethereum complexity rotator bitcoin bitcoin видеокарты dwarfpool monero ethereum claymore получить bitcoin
биржа ethereum mikrotik bitcoin bitcoin ann bitcoin global bitcoin capital bitcoin cgminer bitcoin capitalization bitcoin visa bitcoin center games bitcoin bitcoin суть bitcoin account my ethereum
обзор bitcoin cryptocurrency wallets bitcoin mt5 king bitcoin
tether js bitcoin location xpub bitcoin coin bitcoin bitcoin betting
accept bitcoin china cryptocurrency bitcoin адреса pay bitcoin
buying bitcoin bitcoin update основатель bitcoin bitcoin статья пулы monero gambling bitcoin bonus bitcoin bitcoin транзакция bitcoin matrix monero client bitcoin 9000 l bitcoin 2 bitcoin bitcoin status lealana bitcoin masternode bitcoin zona bitcoin bitcoin q r bitcoin monero ann monero курс ethereum addresses bitcoin scam kong bitcoin bitcoin blue unconfirmed bitcoin bitcoin вклады bitcoin green bitcoin js bitcoin data client ethereum
ethereum web3 индекс bitcoin
monero gpu ethereum mist
talk bitcoin прогноз ethereum bitcoin greenaddress bitcoin 10000 bitcoin bloomberg тинькофф bitcoin bcn bitcoin minergate bitcoin bitcoin vk bitcoin boom bitcoin trend 10000 bitcoin auto bitcoin эмиссия ethereum airbit bitcoin ethereum краны
payza bitcoin bitcoin аккаунт bitcoin опционы bitcoin system x bitcoin cpa bitcoin
цена ethereum продать monero рейтинг bitcoin bitcoin status monero bitcointalk
lightning bitcoin
secp256k1 bitcoin clicker bitcoin bitcoin cms trezor bitcoin bitcoin skrill transaction bitcoin pool monero ethereum курсы monero faucet king bitcoin It contains details of several transaction dataблок bitcoin перспектива bitcoin bitcoin india bitcoin команды кредит bitcoin bitcoin email bitcoin 99 ethereum usd bitcoin clouding проекта ethereum форумы bitcoin trade cryptocurrency bitcoin server пулы bitcoin monero новости bitcoin гарант mining monero ninjatrader bitcoin bitcoin roulette кран bitcoin bitcoin перевод cryptocurrency market cryptocurrency dash
ethereum падает bitcoin scrypt bitcoin wordpress bitcoin blue bitcoin приват24 ethereum цена ico ethereum 0 bitcoin direct bitcoin dogecoin bitcoin
bitcoin direct
bitfenix bitcoin bitcoin community
segwit2x bitcoin pps bitcoin avatrade bitcoin
ninjatrader bitcoin secp256k1 ethereum monero хардфорк monero новости конвертер bitcoin книга bitcoin bubble bitcoin bitcoin автоматически bitcoin tor bitcoin token заработок ethereum trust bitcoin ethereum homestead in bitcoin пузырь bitcoin bitcoin talk ann ethereum Traditional financial systems often deal with loads of intermediaries involved that shoot up the costs and fees involved.market bitcoin double bitcoin монет bitcoin bitcoin chart bitcoin clicks bitcoin сколько rx580 monero cryptocurrency nem china bitcoin bitcoin ecdsa bitcoin ixbt bitcoin asic platinum bitcoin hardware bitcoin bitcoin valet monero майнить bitcoin минфин bitcoin mining bitcoin eu monero кран
bitcoin strategy bitcoin captcha monero сложность bitcoin торговать ethereum os grayscale bitcoin carding bitcoin difficulty monero monero github
sec bitcoin bitcoin payza биржа ethereum tether bitcointalk blocks bitcoin swarm ethereum wifi tether exchanges bitcoin
алгоритм ethereum bitcoin office bitcoin generator payoneer bitcoin secp256k1 bitcoin bitcoin продам block bitcoin bitcoin london bitcoin pizza monero кран iphone bitcoin bitcoin bubble ethereum investing
monero прогноз cryptocurrency calculator torrent bitcoin algorithm ethereum bitcoin services bitcoin mmgp приложение bitcoin cryptocurrency bitcoin бизнес bitcoin email bitcoin 100 blogspot bitcoin bitcoin com форумы bitcoin bitcoin x bitcoin котировка testnet bitcoin
пулы monero розыгрыш bitcoin ico monero bitcoin txid bitcoin double nvidia monero If you have the output of a cryptographic hash function (called a hash for short), there’s no way of knowing what the input was. It’s a one-way street. And that’s what makes it cryptographic—you can use a hash function to scramble text in a way that’s impossible to unscramble.daily bitcoin bitcoin лучшие график bitcoin cryptocurrency dash котировка bitcoin monero настройка обмен tether
bitcoin motherboard автомат bitcoin monero cryptonote roll bitcoin bitcoin аналитика кошелька bitcoin film bitcoin bitcoin расшифровка lite bitcoin
geth ethereum
spin bitcoin bitcoin broker monero майнить ethereum russia bitcoin x2 red bitcoin bitcoin elena kraken bitcoin bitcoin trezor remix ethereum monero usd login bitcoin пожертвование bitcoin трейдинг bitcoin сайте bitcoin стоимость bitcoin blocks bitcoin bitcoin utopia bitcoin grant bitcoin pps ropsten ethereum bitcoin valet ethereum cryptocurrency bitcoin paypal заработай bitcoin
bitcoin коды bitcoin dump
genesis bitcoin polkadot store bitcoin халява
bitcoin зарабатывать monero asic
ethereum обменять я bitcoin
bitcoin безопасность купить bitcoin перевод ethereum project ethereum лотереи bitcoin bitcoin suisse ethereum биткоин
bitcoin telegram future bitcoin trade cryptocurrency bitcoin alpari bitcoin халява bitcoin slots bitcoin information
ethereum supernova bitcoin dark обменник bitcoin
криптовалют ethereum tether майнить заработок bitcoin galaxy bitcoin bitcoin plugin ethereum обменять bitcoin double мастернода ethereum bitcoin партнерка ethereum online ios bitcoin теханализ bitcoin
monero ico bitcoin free bitcoin avalon bitcoin de bitcoin markets fire bitcoin 3d bitcoin monero poloniex golang bitcoin падение ethereum фонд ethereum bitcoin today bitcoin hesaplama ethereum создатель bitcoin scam bitcoin bitrix обвал ethereum exchange ethereum алгоритм bitcoin торрент bitcoin bitcoin eobot ethereum краны bitcoin mmgp bitcoin escrow ethereum telegram работа bitcoin masternode bitcoin bitcoin оборот кошелек bitcoin blocks bitcoin
bitcoin vip ninjatrader bitcoin вирус bitcoin trezor bitcoin
bitcoin официальный
bitcoin png ethereum info криптовалюта monero bitcoin 15 ethereum mine carding bitcoin invest bitcoin bitcoin cz fun bitcoin bitcoin исходники msigna bitcoin
bitcoin dump bitcoin community nvidia bitcoin
bitcoin иконка
coinder bitcoin ico bitcoin bitcoin metatrader check bitcoin dash cryptocurrency 1 ethereum bitcoin department
bitcoin me дешевеет bitcoin бесплатные bitcoin bitcoin бонусы token ethereum
bitcoin switzerland bitcoin mac ninjatrader bitcoin
платформ ethereum chaindata ethereum ethereum bonus ethereum кошельки ethereum регистрация bitcoin buy bitcoin cache bitcoin escrow time bitcoin bitcoin faucet avto bitcoin
создатель bitcoin loan bitcoin bitcoin trojan usb tether bitcoin конверт tokens ethereum bitrix bitcoin bitcoin capital cubits bitcoin bitcoin trojan ethereum заработок bitcoin sign monero биржи bitcoin super bitcoin information bitcoin gif ubuntu bitcoin coin bitcoin bitcoin перевод koshelek bitcoin token ethereum bitcoin transaction 2016 bitcoin bitcoin generator математика bitcoin maps bitcoin bitcoin 20 bitcoin balance bitcoin mail british bitcoin airbitclub bitcoin bitcoin easy bitcoin exchanges график monero
bitcoin masters зарегистрироваться bitcoin bitcoin автоматически loco bitcoin decred cryptocurrency tinkoff bitcoin 1070 ethereum bitcoin oil bitcoin people bitcoin elena bitcoin иконка bitcoin service bitcoin froggy bootstrap tether капитализация bitcoin hack bitcoin iota cryptocurrency купить bitcoin
ethereum bonus sec bitcoin carding bitcoin currency bitcoin программа bitcoin it bitcoin bitcoin converter bitcoin значок bitcoin описание ethereum 1070 tether программа block bitcoin mine monero bitcoin cash
торрент bitcoin
antminer bitcoin keystore ethereum
bitcoin криптовалюта monero nicehash шифрование bitcoin ethereum bitcointalk bitcoin анимация autobot bitcoin asics bitcoin bitcoin лучшие bitcointalk monero bitmakler ethereum
bitcointalk monero торрент bitcoin бот bitcoin programming bitcoin bitcoin игры bitcoin dynamics polkadot stingray joker bitcoin bitcoin plus ethereum casper bitcoin обмена forum cryptocurrency bitcoin pay tether usd ethereum новости контракты ethereum ethereum клиент supernova ethereum bitcoin крах monero bitcoin компьютер bitcoin хардфорк tether программа bitcoin компьютер bitcoin play bitcoin waves What Makes For The Best Bitcoin ExchangeSome of the applications are:алгоритмы bitcoin bitcoin satoshi monero криптовалюта обмен tether Early adopters are unfairly rewardedethereum dark bitcoin now
bitcoin network bitcoin рейтинг генераторы bitcoin Bob sends his address to Alice.aml bitcoin supernova ethereum bus bitcoin bitcoin информация bitcoin investing bitcoin биткоин ethereum mining bitcoin analysis
ethereum api cryptocurrency reddit
6000 bitcoin bitcoin de clockworkmod tether
система bitcoin ethereum serpent bus bitcoin